Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo Review
Heads up: this post contains affiliate links. If you book or apply through them I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you, and I only recommend what I would use myself.
BOTTOM LINE
Baker's Cay Resort, Curio Collection by Hilton is one of my favorite domestic resorts, a waterfront property in Key Largo with two beaches, multiple pools, nature trails, and kayaks. It suits travelers who want a relaxed Florida Keys base with real resort amenities and a strong points-redemption angle. I booked it with a Hilton Honors free-night certificate on dates when cash rates were pushing $500 a night, which made it a standout value.
The Florida Keys have no shortage of places to stay, but few of them combine a genuine resort feel with a Hilton points play the way Baker's Cay does. It is a Curio Collection property spread across a wooded waterfront site in Key Largo, the first island as you drive down from Miami. Between the two beaches, the pools, and the nature trails, it manages to feel like a self-contained escape.
This is a resort I keep coming back to, and it has earned a spot near the top of my domestic list. It works as a place to actually relax on property rather than just a bed to sleep in between excursions. Here is how it books, what the grounds and amenities are like, and who should point their car south for a stay.
Booking Baker's Cay Resort
This is a Hilton property in the Curio Collection, so it earns and redeems Hilton Honors points and takes free-night certificates. That last part is where the value really showed up for me. Cash rates here can be steep, and on my dates they were running close to $500 a night, so applying a free-night certificate that normally maps to around 95,000 points turned an expensive stay into a very cheap one. We used free-night certificates from the Aspire card that we had banked up during the pandemic, and points bookings skip the resort fee here entirely. We even got a nice view upgrade at check-in without asking.
If you carry Hilton status, ask about upgrades, breakfast, and any elite perks at check-in, and factor in the daily resort charge, which covers a long list of amenities like kayaks, paddleboards, bikes, and beach gear. The resort charge is not waived, so build it into your comparison. For anyone sitting on Hilton points or an unused free-night certificate, this is one of the better places to spend them domestically.
Best cards for booking
To get the most from a stay here, the cards I would reach for are the Hilton Honors Aspire Card from American Express, Hilton Honors Surpass, and The Platinum Card from American Express.
Location
Baker's Cay sits on the Florida Bay side of Key Largo, which is the first of the Keys you reach driving down from Miami. That makes it one of the easiest Keys resorts to get to, roughly an hour and a half from Miami International Airport, so you can land and be checking in without a marathon drive. It is a gentle introduction to the island chain.
Key Largo is the self-styled diving capital of the world, and the resort is well positioned for snorkeling, diving, and boat trips out to the reefs. You are also within reach of John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park and the restaurants and marinas that give the Keys their laid-back character. The location balances easy access with a real sense of being away.
The property occupies a wooded, waterfront site that feels tucked away from the highway, which helps it read as a retreat rather than a roadside stop. Once you are on the grounds, the traffic and bustle of the main road fade into the background. That combination of accessibility and seclusion is a big part of the appeal. There are actually two beaches: Hammock Beach, a jungly, tucked-away stretch that feels almost private, and the more traditional beach that our room looked over. And when you do pay the resort fee, it covers more than most, including beach bike rentals and all the non-motorized water toys like paddleboards and kayaks.
Lobby and Check-In
Arrival at Baker's Cay leans into the tropical, Keys-casual style, with an easygoing feel rather than a formal luxury lobby. Check-in was friendly and relaxed, in keeping with the pace of the islands. The staff got us oriented to the beaches, pools, and trails without any fuss.
The Curio Collection branding means this is a one-off property with its own personality rather than a cookie-cutter chain hotel. That character comes through in the design and the grounds. It sets an unhurried, vacation-mode tone from the moment you walk in.
The Room
The rooms carry a bright, coastal look that fits the setting, comfortable and well kept without trying to be a design showpiece. Depending on the category and any status upgrade, you can land water or garden views across the wooded property. Mine was a pleasant, restful space that did exactly what a Keys room should. Mine was an oceanfront room on the third floor overlooking the main beach, with really nice tile in the shower and a very comfortable king. Two nitpicks: the big TV is not a smart TV, which we discovered on a rainy afternoon when we wanted to stream something, and there is no pull-out couch.
What stands out here is less the individual room and more everything just outside your door. The grounds, the water, and the amenities are the real draw, and the rooms serve as a comfortable home base for all of it. If you can get a water-view category, it is a nice upgrade, but the property itself is the star.
Pools and Amenities
This is where Baker's Cay shines. The resort has two beaches and multiple pools, including a family pool with waterfall features and a separate adults-only pool for a quieter scene. Between the two, you can pick your own pace, whether that is a lively family day or a calm afternoon with a book. The adults-only pool has a grotto feel, with a waterfall that runs during the day, while the family pool and hot tub sit just across the way, so the two crowds never collide. One miss: the tennis courts are currently being used for storage and are in rough shape, so leave the racquets at home. On our rainy afternoon, the lobby’s pool table and shelf of books earned their keep. There is a giant Scrabble set in that same lounge, and the activity programming is real here too, morning yoga included.
The daily resort charge covers a useful set of activities, including kayaks, paddleboards, bikes, beach chairs, and umbrellas, so you can get out on the water or explore the nature trails without extra rentals. The wooded grounds and trails give the property a natural, un-crowded feel that sets it apart from a standard beach hotel. There is enough here to fill several days without ever leaving. A few favorites of mine: the champagne vending machine in the resort shop, the tiki boat that runs sunset sailings for an extra charge, and the little spa near the lobby. The second-floor gym has the Peloton bikes every Hilton is supposed to carry now, and upstairs on the top floor sits Calusa, a second restaurant doing breakfast, lunch, and dinner with mangrove views, which is where my morning coffee came from. For Gold and Diamond members, the daily dining credit runs 18 dollars per person here, 36 for a couple, since Key Largo counts as the Miami area.
Food and Drink
The resort has several dining and bar options on site, including waterfront spots that make good use of the sunset views over Florida Bay. Having real food and drink on property matters at a resort like this, where you may not want to drive out for every meal. It covers everything from a poolside bite to a proper sit-down dinner. The main restaurant runs a Cuban-leaning menu with a nice bar and TVs inside, and hidden up on the top floor of the lobby is Kusa, a breakfast, lunch, and dinner spot with mangrove views where I grabbed my coffee every morning.
Prices at the on-site restaurants run at resort levels, which is standard for the Keys, so budget accordingly. When you do want to venture out, Key Largo has plenty of casual seafood and local spots a short drive away. I liked mixing a couple of on-property meals with a trip or two into town.
Service
Service throughout was warm and laid-back in the best Keys tradition, friendly without being stiff. Staff at the pools, the beaches, and the front desk were helpful and easygoing, which fit the vacation mood perfectly. It felt like a place that wants you to slow down and settle in.
Across my stays here, the consistency of that friendly service is part of why I keep returning. Nothing ever felt corporate or rushed. For a relaxed getaway, that kind of unpretentious, attentive service is exactly right.
Who Should Stay Here
Great fit if
Look elsewhere if
You want a real waterfront resort as your Florida Keys base
You want to be far down the Keys near Key West
You are redeeming Hilton points or a free-night certificate for big value
You want an ocean-surf beach rather than calm bay water
You like pools, kayaks, paddleboards, and nature trails on site
You want a budget motel and do not care about resort amenities
You want an easy drive from Miami without a long Keys haul
You are put off by a daily resort charge on top of the room
✈️ WORK WITH ME
Planning a trip and want it done right? I'm a travel advisor and I book hotels and vacations at no extra cost to you, often with extra perks. Get a free quote and grab my free travel tips on Substack.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I book Baker's Cay with Hilton points?
Yes. It is a Curio Collection by Hilton property, so it takes Hilton Honors points and free-night certificates. I used a free-night certificate when cash rates were near $500 a night, which made it a great value.
Where in the Keys is it?
It sits on the Florida Bay side of Key Largo, the first island as you drive down from Miami. That makes it one of the easiest Keys resorts to reach, roughly an hour and a half from Miami International Airport.
Does it have a beach?
It has two beaches on calm bay water, along with multiple pools. The water is gentle rather than ocean surf, which is common on the bay side of the Keys.
What does the resort charge include?
The daily resort charge covers a useful set of amenities, including kayaks, paddleboards, bikes, beach chairs, and umbrellas. It is not waived, so factor it into your total cost.
Is it good for families?
Yes. There is a family pool with waterfall features plus a separate adults-only pool, along with kayaks, trails, and beaches, so it works well for families and couples alike.
What is there to do nearby?
Key Largo is known for diving and snorkeling, with John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park and plenty of boat trips and casual seafood spots close by. You can fill days on property or head out to explore.
Bottom Line
Baker's Cay Resort earns its spot among my favorite domestic getaways by pairing a true waterfront resort experience with an easy Hilton points play. Two beaches, multiple pools, kayaks, and nature trails give you plenty to do without leaving, and the Key Largo location keeps you close to Miami and the reefs. The daily resort charge and calm bay water are the main things to weigh before you book.
Using a Hilton free-night certificate on dates when cash was near $500 a night is exactly the kind of value that makes points worth collecting, and the relaxed Keys atmosphere kept me coming back. If you want a Florida Keys base that feels like a real resort rather than a roadside stop, this is one I recommend without hesitation.
